I’ll be returning the AirPods 4 tomorrow—not because they’re bad (they’re actually really impressive) but because of one key reason: comfort.

I guess I’ve grown used to the fit of my AirPods Pro 2, especially after switching away from silicone to foam tips. That change made them fit so much better, and I never worry about them coming loose. I fee like I could get into a boxing match and they would stay in! With the AirPods 4, however, I constantly feel like they could easily get knocked out of my ears—they are so light!—especially the right one, which often feels loose after extended use. They’re so lightweight that, after long periods, I also feel like they’re falling out, and I find myself trying to push them back in repeatedly. I also noticed some ear strain after wearing them for a while due to that.

That said, the ANC on the AirPods 4 is surprisingly good—probably about 75% as effective as the AirPods Pro 2 IMO. Sitting in a loud coffee shop, I had no complaints. My AirPods Pro 2 still have an edge, both in ANC performance and sound quality, but I was fine to put my AirPods Pro 2 away for the AirPods 4 w/ ANC. For sound, I’d compare the AirPods Pro 2 to HDR video—vibrant, rich, and deep—whereas the AirPods 4 feel more like a great display without HDR. They’re clear and balanced, but they lack the same depth and bass response. Still, they’re about 80% of the way there IMO, which is impressive.

One thing I did appreciate about the AirPods 4 is how much cleaner they stay compared to the AirPods Pro 2, which tend to get dirtier due to the in-ear tips. This is one reason I bought them, and wished I could have kept them for this. But bottom line—if you don’t like the in-ear fit of the AirPods Pro 2, the AirPods 4 with ANC are a fantastic alternative. But for me, the fit of the AirPods Pro 2 make them the better choice.